Last Updated on
This post contains affiliate links. See my disclosure policy for more information.
Fans of the Mortified Podcast will love these other storytelling podcasts to listen to! Get ready to be surprised and delighted by these stories; some are funny, some are touching, all are told by some very brave people!
I was super happy a few months ago when, while browsing through Amazon video options, my husband agreed to watch Mortified Nation, a screen-adapted version of the Mortified podcast.
Having been a fan of Mortified for so long, I was excited to finally introduce him to live storytelling podcasts.
In this world of highly-produced podcasts - with hosts, editors, and perfectly crafted stories - it's easy to forget that there are regular people out there who are exceptionally skilled at re-telling the most embarrassing or important moments in their lives.
I'm always astonished at the bravery of the people who stand up at Mortified events. Honestly, I cringe at the idea of reading my old diaries and letters to myself; reading them aloud to other people is my idea of torture.
I suppose that's one of the things that makes the Mortified podcast - and the other storytelling podcasts that I've recommended below - so intriguing to listen to. They remind me that I'm not the only one to have gone through awkward, confusing, and embarrassing situations in life.
I've listened to a lot of shows that claim to be like Mortified, but the list below is truly my favorite for fans of storytelling podcasts.
The Best Storytelling Podcasts for Fans of Mortified
Grownups Read Things They Wrote As Kids Podcast
Someone will probably yell at me for calling this "the Canadian version of Mortified", but it pretty much is. If you just can't get enough Mortified, this podcast is the most similar.
The stories are recorded live on-stage in Canada, and there are over 600 episodes to binge through!
Like "the US version", the episode descriptions for Grownups Read Things They Wrote As Kids give you just a taste of what you can expect. You really don't know what you're getting yourself into with any episode!
Listen to Grownups Read Things They Wrote As Kids
The Story Collider Podcast
Here's a twist on the live storytelling podcast: this one is about science.
I love Story Collider because the stories are all related to science in one way or another. Some are very directly related and obvious; others just touch on how science was involved in an important part of someone's life journey.
If you're not sure if this show is for you, try this episode about new places and fitting in.
The Nocturnists Podcast
Here's another storytelling podcast with a slant: this one features doctors who stand on stage to share the stories that have shaped their lives and careers.
The team behind The Nocturnists say it is rooted in a "deep-seated curiosity about health, illness, and human connection". I think this is a perfect description for what listeners get.
This is a newer podcast compared to those listed above. It's currently in Season 2, but I'm a huge fan already. I recommend the episode titled, Even the Morgue Has a Waiting List.
The Moth Podcast
No list about live storytelling podcasts would be complete without The Moth. They have been doing live events since 1997 (really!).
22 True Crime Podcasts You've Got to Check Out
Sign up to get your FREE true crime podcast list!
10 Things That Scare Me Podcast
This podcast doesn't include recordings from a stage with a live audience, but I don't think that stops the contributors from feeling vulnerable.
10 Things That Scare Me features short episodes (they average 5-8 minutes) in which one person talks about their biggest fears. Sometimes the person will give context in the form of a short story; sometimes they will just quickly rattle off the fears in a list.
If saying your deepest, darkest fears out loud seems uncomfortable (or terrifying) to you, check out the brave souls who have submitted their recordings to this podcast. Episodes drop every Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday
Listen to 10 Things That Scare Me
Bonus Storytelling Podcast Recommendations
Story Worthy is a podcast that features actors, comedians, and writers telling stories that have had a profound effect on their lives. Host Christine Blackburn chats with the guests at the front and end of the show, providing context around the guest and their experiences.
Pro Tip:
If you're looking for more storytelling podcasts, go to your podcast player and search for "story slam". You'll find several storytelling podcasts from all over the world.
Your Recommendations
What's your favorite storytelling podcast that's like Mortified? Leave a comment below with the podcast name and link, so other podcast fans can find it!
